15 Best Hotels in Mystic Connecticut: Where to Stay in 2023!

*This site uses affiliate links; if you make a purchase through these, I may receive a small commission at no cost to you.

Beautiful coastal scenery, delicious food, and epic seaside history are all awaiting you in Mystic, Connecticut! This is one of the top-rated destinations in New England for a reason.

In the summer, Mystic is a gorgeous seaside destination with lots of walkable attractions, and in the winter, it’s the perfect cozy holiday getaway.

If you’re planning a trip to Mystic, where to stay is probably at the top of your mind. Luckily, this post includes all of the best hotels in Mystic, Connecticut!

#1 Top Pick
Couple toasting with wine glass on romantic getaways in Connecticut

Whaler’s Inn


🍁 Historic & Elegant

🍁 Very Highly Rated

🍁 Top Restaurant Onsite

#2 Pick
Historic Mystic village at sunset with whispy grass in the foreground, the river and town beyond with the sunset above reflecting in the river below

The Taber Inne


🍁 Downtown Mystic

🍁 Heated Indoor Pool

🍁 Highly Rated

#3 Pick
A candle holder with candles lit sits on a table beside fresh cut flowers and a meal with a glass of wine

The House of 1833


🍁 Unique

🍁 Historic

🍁 New England Candlelight Breakfast


Best Hotels in Mystic Connecticut

Historic Mystic village at sunset with whispy grass in the foreground, the river and town beyond with the sunset above reflecting in the river below

The Inn at Mystic

3 Williams Ave, Mystic, CT 06355

First up is The Inn at Mystic, a gorgeous hotel that sits on top of fourteen acres of land with incredibly epic views of the water. It’s only a mile from the seaport, making it an ideal location for a stay in Mystic.

The Inn first opened in the 1980s and has been a classic accommodation and event space ever since. They host tons of weddings in the area at Haley Mansion but also serve as a unique hotel.

The rooms range in size, so no matter what you’re looking for, you’ll be able to find a great place to stay here.

If you get hungry during your stay, don’t worry. There’s an on-site dining option called Rocks 21 Restaurant and Bar that has a lovely outdoor patio with seating.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

Steamboat Inn

73 Steamboat Wharf, Mystic, CT 06355

The Steamboat Inn is a three-star hotel on the wharf, overlooking the Mystic River.

Waterfront hotels in Mystic CT are the perfect hosts for a stay in this charming coastal town, and The Steamboat Inn certainly fits the bill!

Plus, it’s just a short distance from the Mystic Aquarium and the Mystic Museum of Art.

Rooms vary in size, and some offer seafront views while others look out into the town. Oh, and here’s something pretty unique about this waterfront Mystic hotel: there are wine dispensers in the guest rooms!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

Stonecroft Country Inn

515 Pumpkin Hill Rd, Ledyard, CT 06339

For another gorgeous historic accommodation, consider staying at the Stonecroft Country Inn. Located on Pumpkin Hill Road in nearby Ledyard, it is technically slightly outside of Mystic, but it’s still a short drive to get downtown.

Because it’s somewhat out of the central area, it provides the perfect serene setting for a Mystic, Connecticut vacation!

This is a bed and breakfast in Ledyard that is situated on 6.5 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds.

It’s also on the National Registry of Historic Places, and guests rave about the country breakfast offered at this romantic inn.

They have a wide variety of room options and specialty suites. If you’re looking for a romantic getaway, consider booking The Shubel Master Suite!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

Read Next: 10 Dreamiest Connecticut Bed and Breakfasts To Book ASAP

Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic

6 Hendel Dr, Mystic, CT 06355

A plate of eggs and waffles sits beside fresh fruit, syrup, and a cup of coffee
Photo courtesy of Hampton Inn; complimentary breakfast is always a perk!

If you’re looking for more affordable places to stay in Mystic Connecticut, consider the Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic.

Even though this is a popular hotel chain across the United States, it’s highly rated and is a great budget friendly hotel in Mystic! Comparatively, of course.

Just a mile from Mystic Seaport and a short drive to Olde Mistick Village, it’s conveniently located, as well.

Amenities include an indoor pool and complimentary hot breakfast… gotta love hotels with free breakfast!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

The Whaler’s Inn

20 E Main St, Mystic, CT 06355

The Whaler’s Inn in is always at the top of the list of the very best hotels in Mystic Connecticut.

Historic, elegant, and full of amenities, how could it not be? It’s even home to one of the best restaurants in Mystic, The Shipwright’s Daughter.

Closely located to the Mystic Seaport Maritime Museum, The Whaler’s Inn is a great place to consider staying. Amenities are abundant here, including complimentary coffee and cookies in the afternoon, boxed waters in the rooms, discounted tickets to local attractions, and they even have Tesla charging stations.

If you’re looking for a little coastal elegance, The Whaler’s Inn is a great choice!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

The House of 1833

72 N Stonington Rd, Mystic, CT 06355

For one of the more unique historic hotels in Mystic, consider staying at The House of 1833.

It’s located on a few acres of land that are lovely for exploring. It’s also a bed and breakfast, so that homey and cozy vibe is a given!

It’s only a few miles from The House of 1833 to the Mystic Aquarium and the Mystic Seaport Museum, so it’s a great place to use as your home base when visiting the area.

The bed and breakfast is located inside of an early nineteenth-century mansion that was built by a banker named Elias Brown. Brown’s relative still owns the place today.

One of the most amazing things about staying here is that guests will enjoy beautiful gourmet breakfasts that are served by candlelight with traditional New England foods! Talk about a unique Mystic Connecticut place to stay!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

The Inn at Stonington

60 Water St, Stonington, CT 06378

Large white hotel with black shutters and a red door under a dark blue sky.
Photo courtesy of the property

Another one of the most popular places to stay near Mystic is The Inn at Stonington. Located in quaint Stonington, it’s only five miles from downtown Mystic, and it is stunning.

Interior of a bedroom in a hotel. The bed is plush and is made with a tan comforter. Behind the bed is a fireplace on with artwork above the mantle.
Photo Courtesy of Inn at Stonington

This is a smaller inn with only eighteen rooms in total, so if you’re interested in staying here, you’ll want to book as soon as you can. It’s located right near the waterfront, so the sunsets (and sunrises if you can get up that early) are truly breathtaking.

Stonington itself is also a great place to explore if you stay here, with boutique shopping and great restaurants.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

Holiday Inn Express Mystic

6 Coogan Blvd, Mystic, CT 06355

While you may be surprised to find another major chain like the Holiday Inn Express on this list of hotels in Mystic, it serves as one of the top places to stay in the area if you’re looking for convenience.

It’s in a fantastic location: from the Holiday Inn Express Mystic, you only have to walk about three minutes to get to Olde Mistick Village. That’s great!

Rooms are pretty traditional to what you’d expect to get from a chain hotel branch. There’s complimentary breakfast, suites with living rooms, pull-out sofas for extra guests, and an indoor pool.

Complimentary breakfast, people!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!

Orchard Street Inn

41 Orchard St, Stonington, CT 06378

Yellow house surrounded by shrubs and trees
Image courtesy of Orchard Street Inn

The Orchard Street Inn is also located in Stonington, not that far from downtown Mystic. This is an unassuming yet absolutely lovely accommodation, and it’s a great bed and breakfast run by locals in the area.

Amenities in each room at the Orchard Street Inn include television, DVD players, fridges, and more. Some of the rooms also have living rooms and even private patios.

This is a quiet place to stay because the Orchard Street Inn is located on a residential street. If you’re looking for calm, local hospitality, this is it!

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


The Captain’s Mansion (Formerly the Spicer Mansion)

15 Elm St, Mystic, CT 06355

You may remember this gorgeous historic property as the Spicer Mansion, but it’s now been rebranded and rejuvenated to be a sister property of Steamboat Inn!

The Captain’s Mansion is an historic 19th-century Victorian mansion near the Mystic train station and library.

Historically, this mansion used to belong to a man named Captain Elihu Spicer. It served as his summer home and was restored significantly over the years.

Guest rooms at this historic mansion hotel in Mystic are decorated with a classic coastal feel, and enhancements are available for your stay including a romantic picnic lunch! This would be a lovely option for couples looking for a quiet place to stay in Mystic, Connecticut.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


Hilton Mystic

20 Coogan Blvd, Mystic, CT 06355

A part of the reliable Hilton brand of hotels, the Hilton Mystic is one of the most highly rated hotels in Mystic. This hotel is seriously gorgeous!

Modern decor and amenities make this a fresh place to stay in Mystic, plus, you just can’t beat the location. You’re literal steps away from Mystic Aquarium, so this is one of the top places to stay if that’s your main draw to Mystic.

The Hilton Mystic is popular with both couples and families, and breakfast is offered onsite but it is not complimentary.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


Hyatt Place Mystic

224 Greenmanville Ave, Mystic, CT 06355

One of the Mystic hotels that’s perfect for families, this reliable name brand place to stay has everything you might need.

Hyatt Place Mystic has a nice outdoor pool that could be perfect for letting the kids blow off some steam at the end of the day, and there’s even a fitness center, onsite dining, and a business center if there’s something that really and truly cannot wait.

Just a little over a mile from historic downtown Mystic, you’re perfectly situated for a great Mystic vacation.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


Taber Inne

66 Williams Ave, Mystic, CT 06355

Historic, charming, and surprisingly one of the more affordable places to stay in Mystic is the Taber Inne and Suites.

Guest rooms span twelve buildings on 2 acres of lovely grounds, and the amenities on offer are practical, yet there’s still a boutique touch to this Mystic inn. In fact, it’s home to the largest heated indoor hotel pool in Mystic, and the only indoor pool in downtown Mystic!

Opt for one of their luxury suites and your room will have a fireplace, jacuzzi, and balcony, and this property is within walking distance of downtown Mystic, the Mystic Seaport, and Williams Beach.

This is one of the most highly rated Mystic hotels on this list, and it’s one of the most affordable, too! Those two things don’t always go together, so certainly keep this on your list of potential places to stay in Mystic CT.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


The Mermaid Inn of Mystic

2 Broadway Ave, Mystic, CT 06355

A white driveway leading up to a mansion and a gazebo
Image courtesy of Mermaid Inn of Mystic; this darling B&B is one of the best hotels in Mystic Connecticut!

Now we’ve arrived at one of Mystic’s most charming places to stay: The Mermaid Inn of Mystic.

Housed in a lovely historic home, this is a darling place to stay in Mystic!

This gorgeous Mystic inn is conveniently located in downtown Mystic, so if you’re looking for convenient locations for your visit, this would be a fantastic option! It’s particularly popular for couples as a romantic getaway spot.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


Mystic Marriott Hotel & Spa

625 N Rd, Groton, CT 06340

Technically located in nearby Groton, the Mystic Marriott Hotel & Spa is a very highly rated Mystic area place to stay!

You’ve got onsite dining, an onsite full service spa, indoor pool, and so much more at this gorgeous hotel property. Modern and fresh, this is a great place to choose if you’re not really into the whole historic property bit.

Click Here to Check Prices & Book!


Mystic is filled with great places to stay! No matter your budget or reasons for traveling to Mystic, hopefully, you found an accommodation on this list.

You might also like: