Where to Find the Best Lobster Roll in Cape Cod

Ahhh, the Cape Cod lobster roll! Rich lobstery goodness on a freshly baked roll… does it get much better than that?

If you’re looking for where to find the best lobster roll in Cape Cod, well, you’ve gotta know this is going to be a difficult one to pin down because there are so many fantastic lobster rolls in Cape Cod to choose from!

It’s a hard job but someone had to do it, so we’ve rounded up the top 5 lobster rolls on Cape Cod for you to check out during your next visit to the Cape! Whether you like yours cold or hot, you might just find your new favorite in this guide to the best lobster roll on Cape Cod.

Table of Contents

Skipper Chowder House in South Yarmouth

Oh, where to begin with Skipper Chowder House? A strong contender for the best lobster roll on Cape Cod by any metric, their traditional lobster roll is stuffed full of deliciously creamy lobster meat on a toasted brioche roll, available in either a 4 oz or half a pound portion, but you can also choose The Wicked Awesome lobster roll, featuring half a pound of buttery lobster served hot on a grilled brioche roll. Decisions, decisions, this might be a tough one!

Click Here to Read More Reviews!

Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham

An Eastham staple of 40+ years, Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar offers their lobster rolls either cold and creamy or hot and buttery, and honestly, can you really go wrong either way? Tender chunks of lobster are the star of the show here always, but Arnold’s also pairs their lobster rolls with fries and their signature coleslaw, so there’s no leaving this seafood shack hungry! Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar is cash only, but there is an ATM on site if you need one.

Click Here to Read More Reviews!

Chatham Pier Fish Market

If you’re looking for the freshest of the fresh seafood on the Cape, it’s always best to go straight to the source, and at Chatham Pier Fish Market, you’ll be able to watch as the daily catch is brought on to the pier! The lobster roll at Chatham Pier Fish Market is a delectable choice whether you choose it served warm and buttered or cold and creamy because both come piled high on a brioche bun that complements the sweet lobster meat perfectly! Served alongside coleslaw and fries, if you’re looking for a fresh and fabulous lobster roll on Cape Cod that will fill you up perfectly, visit Chatham Pier Fish Market!

Click Here to Read More Reviews!

Seafood Shanty in Bourne

Located in the Upper Cape, the Seafood Shanty is unassuming from the outside and one of those places that would be easy to drive right past… but if you’re looking for the best lobster roll in Cape Cod, you definitely should not! Generously piled atop a soft, lightly toasted roll, their cold lobster roll is creamy, flavorful, and the perfect accompaniment to the fries and housemade slaw that are served on the side. Cash and outdoor dining only, picnic tables offer a fantastic place to enjoy each delightful bite of one of the best lobster rolls on the Cape!

Click Here to Read More Reviews!

The Lobster Pot in Provincetown

The white and red Lobster Pot building is seen with its iconic red neon signage on a sunny day with a bright blue sky overhead — *Editorial credit: Dan Hanscom / Shutterstock.com*

Located in Ptown in the red and white building with the iconic blazing red neon sign, The Lobster Pot has been offering up the finest in fresh lobster dishes on the Cape for generations! Not only do they serve some of the best lobster rolls on Cape Cod both hot and cold, but they serve them up with a creamy, homemade potato salad that is its own mouthwatering experience! The Lobster Pot is always worth the trip to the tip of the Cape!

Click Here to Read More Reviews!

From the Upper to the Outer Cape, there are obviously plenty of options for where to find a good lobster roll on Cape Cod, but if you’re looking for the absolute best lobster roll on Cape Cod? Well, we think these 5 are the strongest contenders for the best lobster rolls on the Cape… we’ll leave the ultimate taste-testing mission up to you to decide, of course!